This week, I have my first in-season 2025 Dynasty Superflex Rookie Mock Draft for you. Take a look at the pre-season 2025 Dynasty Rookie Mock Draft to see how players have changed after the opening few weeks of the college football season. Also, if you play dynasty and want personalized team advice, click the link below and shoot me a message!
Round One
1.01 – Tetairoa McMillan (WR, Arizona)
McMillan has cemented his place at the top of rookie drafts, Superflex or not. He’s shown domination at all levels of the field. He may not be the type of wide receiver prospect we saw at the top of the 2024 NFL Draft, but right now, he looks like he could crack the top 10 of the 2025 NFL Draft.
1.02 – Ashton Jeanty (RB, Boise State)
Jeanty’s performances early in the season should have put to rest the worries that doubters had heading into the season. He’s performed against top competition, he’s continued to break tackles at an amazing rate, and he’s been effective running between the tackles. Jeanty is a perfect back for the modern NFL.
1.03 – Luther Burden (WR, Missouri)
Burden hasn’t been as involved early on as some would hope but at no fault of his own. Burden continues to get open with his great route running, but the offense has managed to be effective spreading the ball around and running the ball against lesser competition. Burden continues to be a clear 2nd wide receiver in this class (that is, if Travis Hunter declares as a defensive back).
1.04 – Cameron Ward (QB, Miami)
After being spoiled with top quarterback talent in the 2024 NFL Draft, the 2025 class has much less proven talent. To me, Ward has stepped well above the crowd at the position. He has noticeable poise, a very strong arm, great athleticism, and can move out of the pocket and deliver the ball accurately. Ward is the only quarterback in this class I see as being worthy of a 1st round NFL Draft pick.
1.05 – TreVeyon Henderson (RB, Ohio State)
I’m not in line with consensus here, but I see Henderson as the best back at Ohio State this season. He hasn’t needed to show off his pass-catching, but we’ve seen what he can do there in previous seasons. What he has done is show off great explosiveness, quick cuts, and improved running ability between the tackles. I think Henderson has the potential to be a 3-down workhorse in the NFL, a position that is currently endangered at that level.
1.06 – Elic Ayomanor (WR, Stanford)
Ayomanor is a player who takes some projection to rank this high. He’s only in his 2ndhealthy college football season and has looked like one of the more dominant physical presences right off the bat. His route running and run-after-the-catch skills have taken a step forward this season, but there’s still room for a lot of growth from the young receiver. With upcoming matchups against Clemson and Notre Dame, we’ll get a chance to see Ayomanor against some top competition this season. This Stanford team is clearly better when they get the ball in Ayomanor’s hands, and they should continue to do so.
1.07 – Quinshon Judkins (RB, Ohio State)
Ranking Henderson above Judkins doesn’t mean I don’t think Judkins will be a successful NFL player. He’s looked great with Ohio State so far and has taken full advantage of his opportunities. I don’t see the same pass-catching and explosiveness in space that I do with Henderson, but I see a back that could immediately step into a starting role in the NFL and handle a significant carry share.
1.08 – Isaiah Bond (WR, Texas)
The young Alabama transfer looks like he made the right decision heading to Texas. He’s been used in more ways than just the screens and go routes he saw previously. Bond’s speed allows him to dominate on those deep routes and screens in space, but he’s also shown improved route running on routes over the middle of the field.
1.09 – Xavier Restrepo (WR, Miami)
Restrepo doesn’t jump off the page with the size or athleticism that some other prospects have. He makes up for that with the steadiness and effective route running needed to always be open when needed. There will be an NFL team that covets Restrepo’s great hands and reliability out of the slot in the 2ndround of the NFL Draft, if not the late 1st round.
1.10 – Omarion Hampton (RB, North Carolina)
In a deep running back draft, Omarion Hampton is going somewhat under the radar. He is an aggressive runner who bursts through any hole that opens slightly for him to pick up yards. He’s not going to bounce around in space and be elusive, but he will run through arm tacklers with ease. Hampton has also shown that he’s an entirely capable pass catcher, which is something that’ll be beneficial for fantasy managers.
1.11 – Emeka Egbuka (WR, Ohio State)
Egbuka could certainly go higher than this come draft season if some of the receivers listed above him don’t continue to improve as expected. The ceiling with Egbuka isn’t great, but he’s a steady receiver who could certainly slot into a solid number two role on an NFL team.
1.12 – Carson Beck (QB, Georgia)
You may have forgotten that this was a Superflex draft up until this point, as Beck is only the 2nd quarterback off the board to close out the 1st round. Beck is an accurate passer that takes what is given to him. The problem is he hasn’t shown anything beyond that. His inability to push the ball downfield makes it hard to project him as a long-term starter in the NFL. I think Beck is the most likely, outside of Ward, to find himself in a position to start early in his NFL career, but I question whether he’s seen as a long-term solution in that role or just a stopgap.
Round Two
2.01 – Quinn Ewers (QB, Texas)
Ewers has the best chance of moving into the top tier of quarterbacks with Ward. If it weren’t for some occasional struggles with accuracy, he’d be a lot higher here. He has a chance to prove himself with a tough schedule upcoming.
2.02 – Sheduer Sanders (QB, Colorado)
Sanders is the 2nd most talented quarterback in this class. On the field, he’s shown enough to be a 1st round NFL pick. The problem is the off-field questions. Blaming teammates for the struggles of the offense is not something you want to see from a player who you’re looking to hand the keys to the franchise. Quarterbacks in the NFL need to be leaders and good representatives of the team. While Sanders is good, he’s not good enough to ignore character questions. If Sanders can show some more maturity as the season progresses and through the pre-draft process, he has a chance to go much higher than this.
2.03 – Jaxson Dart (QB, Ole Miss)
Dart has looked excellent all around so far this season. One of the best deep-ball throwers this season is a skill that has put him squarely in the mix of the 2ndtier of quarterbacks in this class. If he can keep it up through the whole season, he may find himself topping that 2nd tier.
2.04 – Colston Loveland (TE, Michigan)
Loveland is adjusting to a very different Michigan offense than we saw a year ago. Even then he’s been very effective as a pass catcher and is clearly the top tight end in this draft class. He has a chance of pushing for 1st round NFL Draft consideration if he continues to perform in this offense.
2.05 – Conner Weigman (QB, Texas A&M)
Weigman came out and started the season very rough. With the lack of data we have on Weigman, those bad performances really hurt. Weigman still has the talent to be a starting quarterback in the NFL. If he can show more composure against top competition as the season progresses and keeps his accuracy in check, he could move his way back up this list.
2.06 – Tre Harris (WR, Ole Miss)
Harris has been on fire to start the season. The receiving yard leader among Power 5 receivers, Harris has looked dominant early in the season. Pre-season expectations can only last so long, and Harris may find his way climbing much higher if he keeps up this production.
2.07 – Nicholas Singleton (RB, Penn State)
Singleton is a prototypically built running back. He’s big, strong, has great top-end speed and defenders look hopeless against him once he breaks into the secondary. I’ve seen the big plays, but I’m left wanting more on so many carries. For a player his size he goes down too easily on first contact on his runs inside. Singleton has lots of time to rise up these rankings.
2.08 – Kyle Monangai (RB, Rutgers)
Monangai may not be a favorite to be a top draft pick, but he has been a consistent rusher for Rutgers. If he wants to stay in consideration for a Day 2 NFL Draft selection he’ll need to show that he can step up against top competition.
2.09 – Trevor Etienne (RB, Georgia)
Etienne has shown the explosiveness out in space to indicate potential at the NFL level. NFL coaches and front offices love running backs who can make big things happen in space, and Etienne is just that. We simply haven’t seen enough of Etienne yet to say he’s a consistent enough runner to be in consideration for a Day 2 NFL Draft pick, but the potential is certainly there.
2.10 – Antwane Wells (WR, South Carolina)
Wells has put up good production so far this season, but I’m still skeptical about the older prospect profile. Tre Harris has overshadowed Wells so far this season. Wells will need to pull off a few dominant games, which he is certainly capable of, to show that he can earn targets at the next level.
2.11 – Ollie Gordon (RB, Oklahoma State)
Gordon still finds himself in the 1st round of too many rookie mock drafts. A between-the-tackles grinder with a lack of open-field elusiveness that has struggled to run effectively between the tackles against good competition doesn’t warrant that. His huge yardage total from a season ago seems further in the past each passing week.
2.12 – Jalen Milroe (QB, Alabama)
I don’t think Milroe is in consideration to be drafted as a starting quarterback in the NFL. He hasn’t shown the passing ability (or willingness) to succeed at the next level. His amazing athleticism at the position is what keeps him on this list. He’ll likely still be drafted as a late-round flier for a team, and that prospect of him possibly starting will make him an interesting option at the back of the 2ndround of rookie drafts. If he can get on the field, his rushing ability could make him a valuable fantasy asset.