Consensus 2025 Dynasty Rookie Rankings

By Calvin PriceMarch 27, 2025
Consensus 2025 Dynasty Rookie Rankings

2025 Rookie Mock Drafts and Rankings start flooding in this time of year. Especially before the NFL Draft, those rankings vary widely. Until NFL teams commit to specific players in the draft, everyone is going based on their own evaluation of the incoming rookie talent. The format used today is for a 1QB league.

 

 

For this reason, I’ve compiled some of the top rankings/mock drafts from online Dynasty resources and used them to create a consensus top 48 rankings. These can be used to give you an idea of where the market currently is and allow you to identify your own sleepers and values.

 

I’ve used 1QB rankings from eight different sources ranging from February 12 to March 26. I’ve included more detailed information on the sources and aggregation methods below. 

 

Consensus Dynasty Rookie Rankings 

 

1. Ashton Jeanty – RB1 

 

2. Tet McMillan – WR1

 

3. Omario Hampton – RB2

 

4. Luther Burden – WR2

 

5. TreVeyon Henderson – RB3

 

6. Emeka Egbuka – WR3

 

7. Matthew Golden – WR4

 

8. Tyler Warren – TE1 

 

9. Quinshon Judkins – RB4

 

10. Kaleb Johnson – RB5

 

11. Colston Loveland – TE2

 

12. Travis Hunter – WR5

 

 

13. Tre Harris – WR6

 

14. Cam Skattebo – RB6

 

15. Cam Ward – QB1

 

16. Elic Ayomanor – WR7

 

17. Jayden Higgins – WR8

 

18. Devin Neal – RB7

 

19. Shadeur Sanders – QB2

 

20. Dylan Sampson – RB8

 

21. Isaiah Bond – WR9

 

22. Jalen Royals – WR10

 

23. Xavier Restrepo – WR11

 

24. Jack Bech – WR12

 

 

25. Bhayshul Tuten – RB9

 

26. Harold Fannin Jr – TE3

 

27. Jaylin Noel – WR13

 

28. Damien Martinez – RB10

 

29. Elijah Arroyo – TE4

 

30. Ollie Gordon – RB11

 

31. RJ Harvey – RB12

 

32. DJ Giddens – RB13

 

33. Jaxson Dart – QB3

 

34. Tez Johnson – WR14

 

35. Trevor Etienne – RB14

 

36. Mason Taylor – TE5

 

 

37. Savion Williams – WR15

 

38. Jordan James – RB15

 

39. Brashard Smith – RB16

 

40. Jalen Milroe – QB4

 

41. Kaden Prather – WR16

 

42. Tory Horton – WR17

 

43. Tai Felton – WR18

 

44. Jo’Quavious Marks – RB17

 

45. Quinn Ewers – QB5

 

46. Pat Bryant – WR19

 

47. Dillon Gabriel – QB6

 

48. Gunnar Helm – TE6

 

Ranking Sources

 

 

Below I list the 8 sources from which I found Dynasty 1QB Rookie Rankings. I took the top 48 from all sources except PFF, which only had their top 36 ranked.

 

 

Methodology

 

The average was taken across all 8 sources of rankings for each player. In situations where a player wasn’t included in one or more of the rankings, they were penalized accordingly. For every ranking where they weren’t included, 3 points were added to their average rank (except in the case of PFF, where a penalty of 1 is added due to only ranking the top 36).

 

This system ensures that players that are more routinely ranked across platforms are higher on the consensus link than an outlier that’s ranked highly in one or two rankings, but outside of the top 48 on the others.

 

 

For example, Kaden Prather is ranked 25th in the class in the Footballguys rankings but not included in any of the other rankings. With a simple average, Prather would be ranked 25th in the consensus rankings, but with the penalty, Prather is ranked 41st.

 

While there’s pros and cons associated with any way of aggregating rankings, I believe this strategy best represents how prospects are currently viewed in the general Dynasty community.